When Boys Become Boys | Messages and Development of Masculinity
Real Men Feel invites you to redefine masculinity in today's world. The only definition of masculinity that matters is yours. We remind men that they are human beings and have the right to experience and express all of their emotions.
One of the most mentioned books among Real Men Feel's learned guests is When Boys Become Boys: Development, Relationships, and Masculinity, by Judy Chu. Based on a two-year study that followed boys from pre-kindergarten through first grade, When Boys Become Boys offers a new way of thinking about boys' development.
Judy Chu is an educator, researcher, and author. She teaches a course on Boys' Psychosocial Development at Stanford University. Her book, When Boys Become Boys, highlights boys' relational strengths and how boys' gender socialization can impact their development, relationships, and well-being.
She also co-edited Adolescent Boys: Exploring Diverse Cultures of Boyhood. Judy currently serves as Chair of the Global Men's Health Advisory Committee at Movember and co-Chair of the Board of Directors at Equimundo: Center for Masculinities and Social Justice. She also advises The Partnership for Male Youth and the Boys' Club of New York.
Join us and discover how the comments of one thirteen-year-old boy launched a career. Judy shares that boys yearn to find out how they can show themselves to others without putting themselves at risk. The pressure to conform and be welcomed as "one of the boys" is intense and persistent.
Boys and men desire genuine, meaningful connections with other people, but some traditional masculinity aspects make such connections challenging. If you can't be your authentic self, having genuine, meaningful relationships is nearly impossible - yet those relationships are what boys long for.
I had no idea that the masks many men wear start as early as they do in preschool. This conversation was enlightening and sad at the same time.
Topics and Questions
- 1:25 - You do a lot in support of boys and young men. What first got you interested in that topic?
- 4:06 - Were these boys opening up and talking to anyone else?
- 6:17 - Tell me about the study that led to When Boys Become Boys.
- 10:20 - The three main points of the book.
- 12:27 - Does the pressure to confirm kick in when boys start going to school?
- 14:36 - Were the boys aware of the pressure to be more "masculine?"
- 20:07 - How long did you observe this group of boys?
- 22:23 - What surprised you the most in your research?
- 24:43 - What are the masculine norms for a boy in Kindergarten?
- 27:22 - Was there a price to pay for the boys changing their behaviors?
- 29:39 - Are masculine qualities more innate or learned?
- 31:21 - Based on what you've learned, do you have advice for parents?
- 38:00 - What's the best way for people to learn more about everything you are up to?
"In an ideal world, you could be yourself without the risk of threat or punishment." - Judy Chu
Links
Judy Chu -- https://judyychu.wordpress.com
LinkedIn -- https://www.linkedin.com/in/juchu/
Connect with Andy and the Real Men Feel Podcast:
Interested in a Clarity Call with Andy? - visit theandygrant.com/talk
Instagram | @realmenfeelshow & @theandygrant
Personal Website | theandygrant.com for coaching, healing, and book info!
Podcast Website | realmenfeel.org for all things podcast-related!
RMF Facebook Group | realmenfeel.org/group
YouTube | https://youtube.com/realmenfeel
0:01 Greetings and welcome to real men. Feel, this is your host author, coach, and healer. And he Grant, you can learn more about me at the Indy Grand.com. Real men, feel invites you to redefine what masculinity means in today's world. The I believe the only difference. The only definition of masculinity that matters is yours. We remind me that you're human beings and have the right to experience and express all of their emotions. We have conversations that most men are not having but that all men can benefit from You know, one of the most mentioned books, the many learned guests of real men feel have said to me is when boys become boys, development relationships and masculinity by Judy, Judy. Judy is an educator researcher and author, she teaches a course on boys, psychosocial development at Stanford University for book.
0:46 When boys, become boys highlights, boys, relational strengths and how boys gender socialization can impact their development relationships and well-being. She also co-edited adolescent boys, exploring diverse cultures of Boyhood. Good Judy. Currently serves as chair of the global Men's Health advisory committee at movember and co-chair of the board of directors X at X Commando the center for masculinities and social justice. She also advises the partnership for male Youth and the boys club of New York. I recently discovered, we had a number of connections and comment on LinkedIn. So, I reached out and I am very psyched to say, welcome to real men, feel Judy. Thank you so much, Andy. It's a pleasure to be here with you. You do an amazing amount of support for boys, and Men at. So, the first thing comes to my mind is, like, what, what got you interested in that to begin with? Oh, well, actually, it was boys who kind of led me to the work. I was spending a lot of time might, I have a younger brother who's nine years younger and so after my first year of graduate school, I went home and was basically chauffeuring a bunch of 13 year old boys around and they were asking, you know what, I was learning at Harvard and you know wanting to be impressed or whatever.
1:55 And I told them oh well, one of the most interesting things I've learned And this year was near the work of Carol Gilligan who eventually became my academic advisor and she had been doing this work with adolescent girls and kind of what girls were going through adolescence and how does best support them and the things that they were coming up against and all that stuff. And one of the boys said to me, you know, that's important and good. But you know what, you know, we have something to say to their stuff going on for us to and nobody's looking at boys. And so he decided for me, he said you should study boys, you can start with me. And so I kind of sat with that, took it back with me. You know, when I went back in the fall, the school and mentioned it to Carol and she said, you should talk to him, you know, clearly he's interested and wants to say something. And so for her class, which I was taking that semester on clinical, interviewing I, you know, use that opportunity to interview him, he talked for two hours about his various things that were going on his relationships, you know, just messages.
2:53 He was getting about what a me and you're just all the questions that he had in his mind to talk. And he really did, he was so thoughtful Oil and had a lot to say. And I don't think that he is alone in being thoughtful and having a lot to say. And so that kind of started my whole exploration of, you know, that involved kind of just revisiting what do we know about, boys. I mean, I think a lot of the literature on human development psychology. Kind of assumed we knew about boys and men since a lot of earlier development and psychological studies had been largely based on boys, you know, at a time when they were like, oh, we can just study boys and men and extrapolate from there but they had Did studied boys and men in a way that maybe missed a part of their story or missed something in their experience. And so I had a lot of fun actually. Just, you know, getting to not be a fly on the wall because obviously they knew I was there.
3:41 I really stood out. You know what, I went entered all boys, you know, schools and such but they were so generous and so forthcoming and just kind of saying like, yeah, that's important to ask. Yeah, we can tell you and it's long as they trusted that I was really interested in hearing it. They had so much to share, and I was just lucky and grateful to be there. R. Well, that's phenomenal. So did it see that these boys? But they seemed like they were lying to speak about this where they were. They talking about this to anyone else? Who either were you? The first chance they took, gosh that's a great question. Um, I think that they were, you know, they definitely wanted to talk about it. They weren't they were utterly. I started out them talking with and listening to early adolescence, so kind of 7th, 8th grade.
4:24 And then through high school and definitely they, they Wanted to talk about it, but they weren't sure who with whom it would be safe to do so. And some of them did talk about it, like they're like, oh, you know, in my general peer group, you know, if you kind of spill your guts and tell people these things, they'll just, they'll use it against you, you know, it could be, you don't want to reveal yourself and make yourself vulnerable in that way. But, you know, some of them had close friendships and they talked about the value of that, like, you know, and how important those were to them and how like, you know, my best friend knows me. We can just be each other. He's we're totally different, but we support each other in every way and it just helped. Um to feel like they could get through life's in the inevitable challenges and hurdles, you know, like the sense of being in it together rather than alone was so valuable.
5:07 So that. Yeah, they had a lot of great insights, your things that we might as a society, a tribute to like, oh that's, you know, things that girls talk about with their friends with that guys. Don't that, you know, any of those stereotypes, ready. Completely, you know, irrelevant at the minute. I started listening to these boys and hearing what they had to say because they were, like I said, really thoughtful really attuned. Reading their relationships and the social dynamics and what, you know, kind of track me. I'm really trying to figure out at a time in their lives. Like, what's going on? What's the reality? And how can I, how can I fit in here? Do I fit in? What's my place? How can I show myself to others and not put myself at risk of being teased or bullied? But, you know, really longing for those kind of genuine authentic connections, you know?
5:50 Because of course, we all need that all people need that and it's silly to Discount the possibility that boys and men would want that as well, right? Yeah, I'm glad you said men because I know men at every age, it's that challenge of what can I share? What will be used against me even by my friends? And, you know, just the kind of the ballbusting and ribbing that that guys will do. But I also know that when guys, I'm it like it hurts to like, they know it's a joke, but it still hurts. Exactly, exactly. So, tell me about the study that led to the book. Okay, so so as I said, I started out talking to adolescent boys and when I was, you know, and every week I would meet with my advisor, Carol Gilligan and we would talk about, you know, what I was hearing as I was, you know, interviewing observing it interviewing status and boys and what I was hearing was they were kind of Starting to reconcile not right, not reconcile, its kind of accepting the fact that there is this gap between the way boys are said to be and the way they experience themselves to be.
6:47 And I'm not saying that they accepted it like, oh okay, I'm okay with it. They were just saying, this is just how it is and part of growing up is accepting that people just aren't going to see you for who you are. And they were, it wasn't so much that they were like, telling me as a conclusion, they were almost like asking me. Like, is that what it's like? Is that what you're seeing as an adult? Who's a few years older like, is that what you're fine? Being as well. So but they were kind of coming to feel like, okay. We've had a few years of experience under our belt. It seems like it's just very, very difficult or rare to have spaces where you can be yourself, and you're lucky if you do. But it's just seems very, very rare. And so Carol said, you know, maybe you need to look at earlier, maybe you need to look at a time when they don't think, maybe that's just the way it is when there's still more actively resisting.
7:32 It it's not to say that the adolescent boys weren't resisting it, but they were kind of saying like oh, you know what you like yours. I'll get teased, it hurts when I get teased and this more likely than not people use it against me when I read my review myself. So I think I better just figure out how to be very Savvy, very selective about who I show myself to but accept that for the most part I can't just enter a space and be myself that I need to be careful. And so Carol was saying like, well, maybe go to look younger when they're when they know these rules, haven't said in these rules for engagement haven't yet, set in as the way things are supposed to be. Or have to be. And so they were more openly challenging it like oh, why can't I give my friend a hug or why can't we snuggle together?
8:14 You know, or why can't I just be exuberant and really excited about things because they the rules were just beginning to be introduced. And so Carol encouraged me to look at four year old boys in a preschool setting and sure enough. I mean they were open and just wore their hearts on their sleeves, you know, they would think, you know, their tell you exactly what they were thinking and feeling and so you never had League second guess them because they would show you exactly what it is. Are you hurt my feelings? Or don't boss me around it, just a lot of openness. And so it was at this moment where they could really be honest without having without self-monitoring to the extent that we all learn to do when we're participating in society and at a moment of transition, when they were entering schools for the you know, for some of them for the first time or at least starting to become more invested in like, oh well what does it mean to be one of the boys or what does it mean to? You know, be appropriate and inappropriate boy or a desirable boy.
9:12 What are people valuing in boys and kind of learning to kind of rein in some of that exuberance and figure out like if I want to have status or power or influence. If I want people to take me, seriously, how do I need to act? And so they were becoming again it was very socially adaptive in some way, you know, so that you can see why why they were doing it. But there is also a kind of sense of loss because then you lose that hard on the sleeve. Kind of, you know, come as you are, that enthused that unrestrained, enthusiasm and curiosity and interest starts to kind of get a little bit harder to detect, you know, not as obvious. And so my, my book kind of documents my experience and it wasn't that they told me this was happening, you know, these are far and five-year-old, boys.
9:57 It was that I experienced it in interacting and have interacting with them and having relationships with them. So I always feeling like, oh, they're pulling away or they're being a little more. Discrete or trying to be discreet, you know, in ways that they weren't when yet the beginning of the school year. So that kind of, so that's really what my book was about was really the three. Main things was, first of all, boys have these relational capabilities that are often overlooked and underestimated. Like nobody really talks about it because again, we tend to gender those things feminine like anything. That's good at emotions good at relationships because our society genders them feminine boys. Learn because, boys are supposed to be quote unquote, the opposite of girls over the Is it a feminine?
10:39 They learn. Oh, I'm not supposed to show that as much. And so they've learned to tone it down and be a little more selective about who they reveal those things too. But they're absolutely there and they don't lose those. And then the second thing is that shift that shift in Reading those messages, about what's a real man. What's a real boy or whatever and how they learn? How there's a shift they learned to present themselves in different ways in order to align with kind of societal expectations around masculinity. And but then the good news is that they don't Bass. Like I said, they don't lose those capacities, they continue throughout their lives. As you mentioned, even as men of all ages to seek connections and to resist disconnections. And so to really acknowledge and value that aspect of their humanity is kind of what my work, tries to emphasize and highlight. Because I think that sometimes the stereotypical discourse around what boys and men who they are, or what they're capable of tends to discount or actively, you know, push it. I need them to have feel like they have to hide that or disguise it in some way.
11:42 When in fact, you know, if we think about the most successful leaders or the most successful relationships, how to be a good partner, how to be a good friend, how to be a good father. If you have children, you know, all these things require those relational capabilities to be intact, you know, and valued and able and for boys and men to feel able to show those things. And so they're things that are essential to their health, happiness and success. But yet the messages that they They can sometimes receive about what it means to be a real man can create Conflict for them. In terms of what they feel like they should be embarrassed by our can't show the other people. Sorry, that was a mouthful. There's great grateful, thank you. So does, does it seem to be that the first like societal involved?
12:28 But there are some you start going to school. That's what that's when the pressure to conform really kicks in. I think I can very obviously, because some people in some boys Young Have families who are like, you know, you can do whatever you want, you can say, you're at home, that's fine. Yes, and some some families might be more traditional or just have your for different reasons. Different cultural reasons, different values and beliefs. I think, every parent thinks that they have their kids best interest at heart. So it's just a matter of what they think, will allow their boy to survive and thrive in the world as they know it. And so, I don't think any parent goes out with the agenda to crush their boys. His spirits, I think at that they're saying, you know, the world is dangerous, the world is not always kind when, you know, and that was a huge dilemma actually that the father's expressed when Carol and I met with the father's because we were so struck by how tender and affectionate they were when they brought their boys in in the morning for morning drop-off. And so Carol said, let's meet with the fathers and find out what it's like for them to, you know, experience their boys at this age you know?
13:33 And and the bot father's describe this and you know dilemma of like on one hand Really cherishing hoping their boys never would have to lose that exuberance, that kind of spunkiness that really think just really loving to be with people and that up out their nests and also wanting their kids not to be the one who gets targeted and bullied and, you know, called bad names and so wanting to keep them safe, right? And so there's this balance and it's a horrible choice, you know, for parents and boys to have to make because obviously we'd in Ideal World, you could be yourself and not have to get punished, you know, without the Read or risk of punishment. But, but they also knew, you know, unfortunately, the world isn't quite there yet.
14:14 And, and people could save a think like, this. A, your kid loves this. Pink dress, and wants to wear a pink dress to school. Well, you could say, at home, it's safe to wear this pink dress, but at school, or in society, it's a toss-up, maybe you'll find yourself in a space, that's very accepting. But maybe you'll find yourself in the space where they'll decide, that's a really bad thing. And that's a reality as well. You mentioned that, you know, the boys. Is weren't weren't speaking all of this. That would, it took the Observer you to see some of these changes, but I wonder where they aware of the pressure to, to change at all. I think so. I mean they're aware of expectations and assumptions, right? So they know for instance, if an adult says, what's okay? With one adult versus another like you know, what's up? What's okay to do with this teacher? Who's maybe a little more welcoming of differences and another teacher who has more firm ideas about what's a good kid and how kids should act or How a boy specifically should act.
15:10 So they weren't, you know, like I said, very astute readers of the people and and of each other and they would know how to based on what they were experiencing and serving know how to anticipate like, oh, look at that kid, got pushed around or got made fun of when he showed this. I'm going to be careful not do that. So I would ask them things like you know like are you ever expected to actor? Be a certain way or are there things that you think other people want you to do that? Sometimes you are there times when you don't really want to do them. And what's that like And again, they were really able to describe very clearly what was going on from different perspectives, you know, one boy, told me, you know, I'm actually friends with all of the girls but I don't want, you know, the boss of the mean team which was the boys team to find out because then he'll fire me from his club and then I won't have a club or a team and, you know, and that would be a bummer, you know.
16:00 And so they know what the consequences are and they're already starting to adjust themselves because what motivates them to even want to, you know? No. Aligned with these messages about what boys should be like is that they are again that kind of relational aspect of their existence, which is that they want to identify and relate to the other boys and the other girl, all the kids. But specifically they want to be one of the boys with the boys. And so it's a relational motive that drives the behavior. Not like somebody says, oh, you have to be a man. And therefore, they like, okay, in that case, I'll do this. I mean, there has to be a genuine incentive there and that incentive is so sincere. The motivated by their desire to be in genuine meaningful connection with other people. But unfortunately a lot of the messages that at least a more kind of traditional messages that we have about masculinity, while they are not inherently problematic Duke can make it more problematic.
16:54 I can make it more difficult for boys and men to establish the kind of connections that have been shown to be protective, you know, against psychological risk, like, low self-esteem and depression. I can social risk like, risk of substance use for numbing, you know, Unintended pregnancy school, dropout the best protective factors having those authentic, Mutual relationships. And the pathway to manhood, as kind of traditionally. Spelled out really leads, boys and men away from that possibility. It makes it harder. It doesn't make it impossible, but it makes it harder because in, you know, because relationships depend on how you are present in that relationship. And if you can't be authentically present, then those, those authentic relationships are just that much more difficult to come by, right? Yeah, it's such this.
17:38 This horrible Twisted scenario that even at a young age, at every age men are longing for connection for Community but they these communities and connections are built to Ron wearing these masks. And I so I knew that was the case. I had didn't know it started so young. I really thought there was more kind of, you know, come on in. You know, that again, the teenager prohibitive start putting, which mask should I wear today and how can I fit into? Not be noticed, but that it happens in preschool is just It's very saddening. It is, it is. And actually I just remembered what your original question was was like, how early is it happening? And so, it can happen even earlier than preschool if they're hearing that they're having during those messages and feeling those pressures, even earlier, if they happen to be in an household or just an environment that says, you know, this is for boys. And this is not for boys, then they're going to learn that too, you know?
18:32 And so when they, when I went at the zoo, actually heard a parent, tell their baby, B Boys Don't Cry and I was like that's how babies Express themselves. I think I'm not sure what you want this baby to do other than cry and so you know sometimes the messages are a little bit silly because you know that's just how it is opening every show you open. Like yeah. So many men are taught not to be human right and it's horrible. It's you know it's what creates this, this layer upon layer of fakeness and in authenticity and trying to pretend to get it all figured out and we don't need anybody's help. And it couldn't be further from the truth. Exactly. Because nobody succeeds alone and life is hard and we need people. And to deprive anyone of those resources that are so essential is like I said it's really sad and it and we really put boys and men in a difficult situation when we don't like I think I've compared it to like you know, binding someone's arms and legs and throwing them in a pool and saying swim swim and you're like, okay but let's not you know, create Necessary obstacles.
19:38 When life is hard enough as it is. Yeah. Right. Go survive but without all the tools possible. Exactly. Yeah. And I love you call it the rules for engagement earlier those like never heard that saying, even again at such a young age and the Rules of Engagement for acting like a man or acting like a real boy. It's, you know, I thought the only time I've heard real boy, was, you know, for Pinocchio or something. I didn't realize they, would they do that? This unsaid pressure to even at such young ages. So, so we know you started Interviewing in this study started talking to boys at age 4. So, how long did you? Did you stick with this group of boys with that particular goodbye, followed them weekly for the first year and actually weekly for the second year to so Pre-K and kindergarten and then and then I came back and visited a couple years later to check in with them. I think it, that was third grade 2nd or 3rd grade, just to kind of see, you know, how things had progressed. And then I, after I wrote my book came out, they were much older and I shared the book when I gave coffee. Because of the book to their family, they said, oh some of them are nearby.
20:40 Why don't you call them up? And so I actually had coffee with one of them who was, you know, now the way taller than me, 64 people or and just kind of asked him what, you know what, he remembered. And also I always love to check in with my with the boys who are generous enough to, you know, talk to me like you what did I miss? You know what did I not get? And so for instance one of the boys told me oh one of the things I didn't get at was how close he was with his brother and how important that relationship was precisely because some of the peer. Just were so challenging and so he said it would have been nice if you could have observed us at home to or something. And of course, you know, the study is constrained in a lot of ways. And one of the ways with, I mean, I did make home visits to some of the boys families who invited me to come over and see what their family was like at home. But, you know, definitely, that's that's a very valid point and he and his brother continue to be very close. And they were, you know, always there for each other when sometimes the supports in their peer or other school in a school at The Network's didn't went there in the ways that they needed them to be.
21:41 So totally, at least at least for some siblings. They didn't have to wear that mask. Exactly. Exactly. And it's so important to have those spaces, you know? I mean there's this one study that was the Adolescent health study that was started in the ninth mid 1990s and was longitudinal and that they're the ones who found that the single best protector against those risks. That I mentioned, the psychological reason socialist because having access to at least one close confiding relationship, so that Could be with a sibling, it could be with a friend, with a teacher, a parent, a mentor. I could be with anyone but kids and adolescents who had at least one were much better protected against kind of the risks that can befall our kids, as they're going through, you know, the various challenges of life. I wonder what stood out to you as the most surprising thing from from all this.
22:27 All this research would boys. And I think, but what my, what my partner's is he was, he's always, says, hit the thing that strikes him is that they talk to me at all. You know, I'm this, you know, there are many strikes against me, I was older. I'm, I'm female identifying. And and sometimes and in the beginning, when I was, you know, kind of observing from a distance and trying to give them their space and allowing them to approach me as I felt comfortable. There is a lot of, you know kind of fun around no adults or no girls are no teachers and so it kind of Negotiating that but what I guess what surprised me was the fact that they eventually once they figured out they could trust me that I wasn't going to tell on them that I was really interested in learning from them that I and I would tell them things like, you know, because I was a girl, when I was younger I don't know what it's like to be a boy.
23:16 And so I'd really like to learn and I would love to learn that from you, then they felt like, oh, okay. Then you need to know this and I got to tell you about this and sometimes they would like kind of pull on my like, pulling my shirt tail and be like, Oh, come over here. I got to tell you what. Yesterday. And so I felt again so lucky and so grateful that they wanted to tell me these things and just felt like how fun is this, you know, I mean finding the sense that you know, getting to hang out with them but also also kind of being having the privilege of kind of documenting that so that other people could see. Look at what they can do, look at what they're capable of knowing and doing their relationships. So definitely those stereotypes about, we know what they're like, and they're not being have not having the capacity or desire for real. Leadership, that's all, you know, not true. So obviously not true because they really are eager to connect.
24:05 They absolutely have the capacity and desire to do so and when they do I mean they they are so appealing and so interesting and fun to be with and there's so much to learn from them. I think originally my study was called learning what boys. No or listening to boys voices. I played around with different titles because I'm like this is what I'm doing and and and it's not just it's not like something that was special or unique. To me, I think that anyone who it shows, a genuine shows up with authenticity, the way that you do and really shows a genuine interest in learning, boys can tell them, you know, all about their lives and what they need and what's going on for them. So what sort of masculine Norms are there for a boy in kindergarten? Well, there were all sorts of the boys. Actually, they were so clever.
24:52 They created this club called the mean team to identify your. So, all of the boy, when I've asked them things like, what do I need to do? What would I have to do? If I wanted to be a boy, they say. Well, first of all, you'd have to be a member of the mean team. Because the mean team is for all of the boys. And if you are a girl, then you'd be on the nice team and I said, oh okay. But the thing is, you can get fired from the mean team and end up on the nice team. If you break one of the rules for the, like I said, the rules, For engagement. So like if you're friends with the girls or if you like games that the girl, you know, if you play with dolls, the way that only girls are supposed to play with dolls or or if you or sometimes it was even stuff that was not necessarily transgressing in terms of doing something that was considered feminine. But if you didn't obey what the boss of the mean team was doing, so it if you didn't play along with the hierarchy that had been established, among the boys, that could also get you in trouble. And sometimes it was nice stuff too. Like if you didn't, if you excluded someone, you could get fired from the mean t.
25:46 And so it was just this interesting thing to kind of Keep things feeling safe and more under control. And so they gets to creating a sense of certainty and predictability. Like, if there were these rules and you follow them then you could continue, you know with your membership you can contain have this sense of acceptance and belonging and you know, when I ask one of the boys that girl, what are some of the benefits and what are the good things about being on it, he would say like well, you know, if you have trouble doing something then all of the boys would come to your assistance. You know, they would come and help you do it and so you wouldn't have to be alone but it I always came back to like so there is no it's just motivation like even and even when I said like, oh well, what is what would be mean? What's something that's mean? Like was it actually about cruelty was what kind of what I was getting at. And it wasn't it was more about like mischief and because again, because they had read the read the signs. So to speak like, oh, well, boys are supposed to be rambunctious or mr.
26:38 Bissell. They felt like, you know, sometimes the girls are playing a nice quiet game and you'll come over and you kind of run around them and yell and scream. That kind of thing was was mean, it wasn't about hurting people. And in fact, when He's gonna lie in your somebody accidentally got hurt. You know, one of the boys told me, I don't really want to be a part of that. That's not really something that I want to do. And so you know, feeling conflicted, if things did get, you know, to the point where they were, you know, accidentally hurting somebody, you know, because again, the four year olds, they're not out to, they're not really out to, you know, Express anything that's you know that we would consider cruel or aggressive. It wasn't a full-on Lord of the Flies experience. This mean, Team yet.
27:19 No, no, no. For sure, not. So did you notice and did the boys notice? Was there any sort of price to pay like what was lost for? Not engaging with the nice team? Absolutely, for not engaging with a nice team. I think, you know like that. One boy said he actually enjoyed playing with the girls sometimes, you know, one of the girls was really into Star Wars which had its, you know, second video Star Wars first came out when I was five and then when these kids were five, it kind of made me realize Surfaced. And so they were like she was totally into Star Wars knew all the characters and he thought she was pretty cool and fun and she's had cold toy Studio Millennium Falcon obviously. And so he wanted to play with her and he would have play dates with her but that was the thing where he didn't want the other boys to find out because he was afraid of you know, breaking the rule and then getting fired from the mean team. But that there were consequences to. Like I said, you know when I when you know, why I was saying that that one boy said the advantage was if you needed help, they would help you.
28:16 They had your back so to speak. If You know, the way that older boys will talk about it, but the disadvantages, he goes well, sometimes they want to do things and I don't want to do them. Like, for instance, the example of hurting somebody, like, you know, one, one boy said, oh let's go over and you know, throw these leaves on there, whatever. And he's like he didn't really want to do that or another time he they wanted to play soccer and he wanted to play basketball but he felt like he couldn't do that. And so she said sometimes I want to make my own decisions and I said well why don't what makes it hard to do that and he said well because then I You that, you know, they'll they'll all gang up and come after me. So, kind of deviating or being different. Could result in everybody else deciding. Oh, you're not with us after all. So we're going to team up and be against you. And so, they were again, very aware of what the consequences were of stepping of nonconformity, right? Or stepping outside of the group norm. And, you know, and the been those, they knew it wasn't all good at knew.
29:15 It wasn't all bad. So, even the boy said to me, because I see, It's so overall do you like being on it? He goes well I kind of do but I kind of don't and so they could express that kind of feeling divided. You know, they wanted the sense of group membership but they also felt that you know it did limit their freedom and their choices and sometimes they didn't want to do what the mean team was doing. But they felt like, oh well I have to. So do you find that masculine qualities are more innate or learned? I think. Given that what's considered masculine varies across cultures, I think that each culture or subculture decides what they value in boys and men, and then encourage that. And so I think that individuals are born with temperaments and predispositions.
30:06 You know each of us is unique in that sense, right? And so you could have you know what we would call a tangra tomboy, right? You could have a girl be very masculine but and you could say that that Rate USA. She's really tough and strong and loves to play. And because our society, decides that physical toughness and strength is a masculine thing, you could say that she's very masculine. You could even say that those qualities in her or those skills were innate, but I don't know that it's but that's kind of socially constructed and determined. You know what I mean? She could just as well, you know, it another culture. Like, let's say we had there's a culture where that kind of physical strength, wasn't specific specimen specific to a Under then you could still say it would still be an eight but it wouldn't be considered innately masculine right?
30:52 And so it does that make sense? Like so kind of we assign what we decide is masculine or feminine, but there's definitely things qualities, personality traits, whatever skills interests that are innate that then Society deems gem feminine or masculine. Yeah I got it. No it does make sense. Yeah. Think things are innate but then the labels are not exactly exactly. You said it so much better than I do. To write concisely and clearly thank you. So, based on all your interviews, everything that you've witnessed and picked up from, from boys, and from their fathers, from their parents. What's your kind of best advice for parents with who have young boys now? Josh, I think I think the again Takei because I love I love that they call you the king of authenticity because I think that that's really Central.
31:43 I usually when I give advice and I'm hesitant to do so because I'm not a perfect parent myself. But the things that I strive for our, this kind of authenticity that is not about being perfect far from it. And I find that kids really feel reassured and relieved to know that they had. I mean, obviously, you don't And it everything to be chaotic all the time, but they like to know that it's okay to make mistakes that even adults don't always know and to do it in a way that's kind of reassures them that we're going to help you through this but we can't guarantee anything and that's okay. Life is just like that. Then they don't feel like failures when they come across their own limitations or when they make their own mistakes, you know? And so when and so I guess the advice I usually pass along because it's what I heard from the fathers and mothers of these boys.
32:32 Because eventually the mothers when Heard that we were meeting with a father so they're like, well we want to talk to you too and we want to meet to so. But it's really about, you know, showing up as you know, as humbly and as authentically as you can, you know, and sometimes being like, you know, that's a good question or that that's a real problem. And sometimes, you know, like when father said, you know, his son wanted to know, you know, what our friendships about. You know, what's that about? What are your friends like, what do you like about that? Or what is it? When we get angry? Because we get really angry sometimes and what do we do with that? And to have someone say, No. Yeah. Of course, you're going to feel these things and there are better ways and worse ways to express them. And so let's talk about that. And what do you think about and having that conversation? I think a lot of times that's parents we feel like we need to be perfect and we need to show up as perfect in order to make our kids feel safe.
33:19 But I think that ironically, it's when we are appropriately authentic. Does that make sense? Like we, we don't want to burden them with our troubles but we it's fine to let them know that. Yeah, we're struggling to work. Certainly figuring things out. Things are scary to us, too. And this is what we do and we'll figure it out together. I feel like and so I usually say start with listening right? Start to listening start with listening so that you can find first of all, figure out what exactly they're asking because we I also jump to conclusions like I hear this like oh, they're asking about Gunplay for instance, I'm like, oh no, you know, there's this like automatic slippery slope to does this mean they're going to be violent and aggressive but we're just wondering what it is you know and and at what I think observed with the boys in my Class Act.
34:03 And that in that particular class actually, was at the Gunplay didn't for the boys carry any of the negative connotations. It was just a way for them to instantly relate to the other boys, not because boys have to play with guns, but because the boys in this class happened to play with guns. And so if they said, oh look, here's a Lego. Whatever gun. I see it. You see it, cool. We both see it, right? But then actually that year one of the school shootings happened and that was obviously scary to them. And when that happened, they stop playing with the guns because they hadn't. Is how guns her people. So you know, then you realize oh, it's I think that it's the same thing that, you know, adults do with Barbies and girls. I like, oh no. She likes Barbie. That means she's going to have body image issues, or she's going to think that this is the only one way to be beautiful or whatever. And so adults have a lot of connotations and to kind of stop ourselves from going down our own Paths of associations and check in with the kid.
34:54 And so, again, starting with listening seeing what their questions really are and not necessarily feeling like we have to have the answers but just being with them in the question or something. As being with them in the struggle, like sometimes something hurts and you know, friend doesn't want to be your friend anymore and that sucks. And you're like, yeah, I get that. And they don't want you to solve it for them because then it almost feels like it. Trivializing the problem like, oh, there was a simple solution and why don't you just do this but sometimes they just want someone to hear it and to know what their understand what they're going through. The boys have said themselves, you know, just that sense that someone else knows what you're going through and understands because it's just they said, it's just kind of comforting and I think that's what I think that's among the best things that adults can provide you as parents or teachers or anyone wanting to support Boys and Men actually because, you know, that I hear that an adult relationships often to like know what, you don't need to fix anything.
35:47 Just listen to what I have to say and let it just be. But yeah, so many people keep things pent-up and but especially men were part of the part of our training fix things, take action drive forward and so it can be tough to just oh I just have to nod. That's the Tenth of the interaction. You want from me? Okay, I can do that, right? And it's so well intentioned, right? Our hearts are in the right place and we see someone we care about hurting. We want to fix it for them but then sometimes if we can remind ourselves like when were hurting do we want someone to offer you? No Simple Solutions or sometimes and so it's a constant practice, right? I find it myself too because I'm a fixer to and when somebody presents a problem like oh my gosh what can I do to help you make it better?
36:30 And some things just you know, you can't He can't. All you can do is be there and let them know, you know, you're with them, you understand? And you know, that it's going to get better with time righty. So yeah. So there was a great example. You said you were a fixer, and I'm used to fixer being labeled as masculine and so wanting to fix. Things can be an 8 and then Society goes and blows it and gives it some other label and, you know, Conformity or nonconformity or whatever it might be, but great and that's related to those masks you're talking about, right? Because if we could just come and show up as we are With the whole range of human emotions. How freeing would that be, right? There's no constraint like, oh, if you like this, or you do that or you have this skill or interest then?
37:11 Well, you can't have that because that's a, that's the wrong category. That's not the category you were assigned. It's just like, it's really arbitrary and it's unnecessary. I think that if we could just relax those a little bit and it's that people come as they are and say that, you know, that's fine, that's great. You know, we really need people to be different and to bring different skills and perspectives and opinions to make Society richer. I think that's deaf all ways a plus. And so why why flatten everybody into, you know, one or the other? When there's so much more that we can offer individually? If we're allowed to kind of do the things we most feel passionately about and are good at, don't agree. More awesome, Judy, I find you and your work, fascinating.
37:56 I really want to thank you for joining us today. What's the best way for people to learn more about everything that you're up to? Oh my goodness. Well I have I have a very informal webpage, it's through WordPress and I think it's in the bayou that you included in the description for this should have it memorized but I don't and if they want to reach me I'm on LinkedIn and that's a good way to message me and then I can provide them with my email that way. And so I'm happy to, you know, if I can be of help please reach out and happy to do. So, right. Thanks again for joining us to D. Thanks. To everyone for listening and finding us and please visit real men. Feel that org, there will be a blog post for this episode will have links to all the books and resources mentioned and wherever you're discovering real.
38:42 Men, feel, please give a like, subscribe, share this episode with someone that would find Value in it, which is everybody. And you can always reach out to me at real men. Feel at gmail.com, always glad to hear from you. And if you're not yet in the real men, feel private Facebook group, there is one, and you can get there right away by visiting, real men, feel dot org slash group. And until next time, be good to yourself and the little boys in your life be well.
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Spotify
Amazon Music
iHeartRadio
TuneIn
Goodpods
Podchaser
RSS Feed